Posted August 06, 2013

Report: Second autograph broker says Johnny Manziel was paid for signing

(Scott Halleran/Getty Images)

Reports allege Johnny Manziel has accepted cash for autographing memorabilia. (Scott Halleran/Getty Images)

A second autograph broker has told ESPN that Johnny Manziel was paid for providing autographs. ESPN reports an East Coast broker said he paid Manziel $7,500 for signing approximately 300 mini- and full-sized helmets on Jan. 11-12 while the Heisman Trophy winner was attending the Walter Camp Football Foundation event.

According to ESPN, the broker played two cell phone videos created as proof for authenticating company PSA/DNA. The videos reportedly show Manziel signing white Texas A&M helmets and footballs laid out on a bed in a hotel room. The broker said the room was at The Omni in New Haven, Conn., and Manziel spent about an hour signing three different times on Jan. 11-12. The broker told ESPN Manziel received cash at each of those three signings. The video does not show Manziel accepting money, according to ESPN.

ESPN reports the broker and his partner originally requested money to release the videos for use on ESPN, which ESPN declined to pay. The broker then allowed ESPN’s Joe Schad to view the videos. Later, the broker said he had decided not to sell the videos.

ROSENBERG: Johnny Manziel not one to challenge unfair NCAA rules

“Outside the Lines” reported Sunday the NCAA is investigating allegations that Manziel was paid for signing hundreds of autographs on photos and sports memorabilia while in Miami for the Discover BCS National Championship Game in January. The Texas A&M quarterback could be ruled ineligible if the NCAA findd he violated NCAA Bylaw regarding accepting money for promoting or advertising the commercial sale of a product or service.

From ESPN:

On the videos, which the broker said were recorded without Manziel’s knowledge, ESPN heard Manziel say “you never did a signing with me” and that if the broker were to tell anyone, he would refuse to deal with him again in the future. Manziel, who appeared comfortable throughout the video recordings, also said if asked, he would say he had simply been approached by various autograph seekers.

At one point, ESPN heard a broker ask Manziel if he would take additional cash to sign with special inscriptions, but Manziel declined, indicating he had done that before and it led to questions. The video does not show Manziel accepting cash, which the broker alleges happened three times. The broker told ESPN that Manziel said he wanted money for new rims for his vehicle.

The broker said he secured so many autographs from Manziel that not all of them had been listed for sale. He stated some had been sold on eBay and some had been passed on to dealers. He also said that Manziel’s friend and personal assistant — Nate Fitch — was not present or involved in the alleged transactions.

The broker said he does not intend to cooperate with the ongoing NCAA investigation involving Manziel and autographs . . .”

Sunday’s “Outside the Lines” report included two sources who said they witnessed the January signing in Miami, but neither saw money exchanged for the autographs.

STAPLES: Johnny Manziel discussed autograph incident in July SI interview

An excerpt from that ESPN report:

Three sources told OTL that Manziel signed photographs, footballs, mini football helmets and other items at the request of an autograph broker named Drew Tieman. Two sources, who are aware of the signing arrangement, told OTL that Tieman approached Manziel on Jan. 6, when he landed at Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport to attend the game between Alabama and Notre Dame the next day.

After that meeting, three sources said, Manziel, accompanied by Fitch, visited Tieman’s residence and signed hundreds of items in the main room of the apartment despite the fact there were many people in the room. Before Manziel left South Florida, after taking in the title game, he signed hundreds of autographs more, one source said.

The source also told OTL that James Garland, the NCAA’s assistant director of enforcement, in June contacted Tieman and at least one person associated with the signings. The source said Garland, who did not return calls from “Outside the Lines” for comment, told the person that he wanted to talk about Manziel signing items that had appeared for sale on eBay. An NCAA spokeswoman cited NCAA policy to “Outside the Lines” and declined to comment on Sunday.


There you have it...recorded without his knowledge.  Sounds like the shakedown did not work to keep him signing items so they have gone to the press. " Oh, by the way ESPN, we want you to pay us for these videos". "We are not motivated by money...that was not our reason for coming forward now with these hidden videos."  These guys are trash and their pictures posted on every college campus as a warning to other..."See, this is what happens when you engage in activities with scumbags that claim to be your friends but all the while only see you as a cash cow they can exploit now or blackmail later.  That's my take on it. As for him taking money, I could care less.  Football palaces (see Oregon Ducks facilities), coaches making millions, networks making millions, commercial sales of their likeness making millions, and the NCAA is bichin about a guy that probably got paid some cash for his autograph in college!


The NCAA needs to back off.  They are going to ruin the fun of college football by taking one of the most exciting players out of the game this year.   2nd year in a row that the most exciting player in college football will be missing for the season  (Honey Badger last year)... as a fan, this is very disappointing and while JFB is at fault, the NCAA is over-reaching and shouldn't be targeting their best & most exciting player to eject for the season... he is what makes college football fun to watch

Agreed on the comments below that he comes from money and didn't need to do this...

LorenVanportfleet 1 Like

What a dunce!  He already comes from money and he still screws up.  Now comes the question, how draftable  is he?  Texas A & M did their job and it fell on deaf ears.  Which bring up major issue, is he coachable?


That's a hard call. Apparently his dad has been enabling this attitude of his for years, so he might not have the appropriate respect for authority figures that he's gonna need to make it much further. I think people might be forgetting some of his earlier exploits because of the most recent incidents that have come to light, but he's compiled a lot of bad history in a fairly short time.


@EleuterioVillegas I would like to say I'm surprised, but I'm not.  I would be willing to bet he has demonstrated that behavior for quite some time.  However it has not come to light as of recent developments.  I hope I'm wrong.


Y'know, no matter what side of the "should players be compensated or not?" debate you fall on, I think it's safe to say that this guy and his entitled bs attitude are a textbook example of repeatedly shooting yourself in the foot. It's not because "he's a kid." He's over 18 and I've seen 10 year olds with more sense. It's because he acts like a baby.